cheshire west

Greene King criticised as Blue Cap pub dismissal claim fails

The Blue Cap pub in Chester Road, Sandiway <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
The Blue Cap pub in Chester Road, Sandiway (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A PUB company has been criticised for its treatment of the former manager at a Cheshire West pub after her claim for constructive dismissal is rejected.

Mimi Shore was the general manager of The Blue Cap, in Chester Road, Sandiway, which operates under Greene King's Chef and Brewer subsidiary brand, for more than a decade before she resigned in January 2024.

During a three-day employment tribunal, the 52-year-old mum-of-two claimed actions taken by Greene King during the break down of their relationship, amounted to constructive and unfair dismissal.

But at an outcome hearing on Friday, September 19, employment judge Ann Benson dismissed Mimi's claim.

Employment Judge Benson said, while Greene King's actions were at times 'clumsy, insensitive, and lacking empathy', they did not reach the breach of contract threshold.

A spokesman for Greene King confirmed the company is taking the judge's comments 'seriously'.

"The conduct of the respondent [Greene King], taken on a cumulative basis, demonstrates a lack of empathy and concern for the claimant and her welfare, and a poor management style," said the judge.

"This is a very sad case in which poor communication styles and lack of thought have resulted in a valuable member of staff, who ran a successful and popular pub, losing everything.

"Even though that be the case, she has not been able to prove her case sufficiently to reach the high hurdle of showing that she was constructively and unfairly dismissed.

"I do not find, taken cumulatively or individually, the respondent behaved in a way, viewed objectively, that was calculated or likely to destroy or seriously damage the trust and confidence between the claimant and the respondent."

As well as finding Greene King's actions did not amount to constructive dismissal, the judge also added Mimi, who represented herself during the tribunal, had taken too long to resign and, at one point, 'affirmed her contract' by stating a desire to return to work.

Following the outcome hearing, a disappointed Mimi said: "While I understand I lost the case on a legal technicality, I feel vindicated by the fact the judge acknowledged the failings of Greene King in the way I was treated.

"This has been an incredibly difficult journey, but I am proud I stood up for myself and my principles.

"Although I was unsuccessful, I hope Greene King takes the time to reflect on the poor practice highlighted by my case and make changes so no-one else has to go through the pain I have suffered.

"I am grateful to all my supporters, all the staff, and the customers over the years at The Blue Cap who helped make it the successful business it was.

"I also hope this raises awareness also of the challenges individuals face when taking on large companies."

Employment Judge Benson was also critical of Greene King's preparation for the case.

She added: “Some of the lack of attention to detail in relation to preparation for this case is not good practice.

"The sloppiness which appeared to me to be apparent throughout parts of the respondent's case and this lack of attention to detail is something I wouldn’t have expected to see from an organisation of their size."

A Greene King spokesman said: “We are pleased to have reached an outcome of the tribunal. We respect the process and are glad to have this matter resolved.

"We have taken the comments raised seriously and Greene King remains committed to supporting our customers and teams and to conducting our business with integrity, fairness, and responsibility."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos